There’s nothing quite like a slice of good bread turned into something unforgettable. And this Toast with Basil Pesto, Avocado, Blistered Tomatoes and Feta Crumbs is exactly that. It’s a quick, vibrant dish that brings together creamy avocado, herby pesto, sweet jammy tomatoes, and salty feta – simple summer ingredients layered into one perfect bite.

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

There’s something so magical about a recipe that is born out of necessity. I didn’t set out to create something that would become a staple in my kitchen or a dish I’d write about and share with millions of readers. But life in the kitchen is funny that way – sometimes it’s those unplanned, slightly frantic moments that lead to the most delicious results.

This toast came to life on one of those sweltering summer afternoons when the air feels heavy, and even thinking about turning on the oven feels like too much. I had a mound of cherry tomatoes sitting on the counter, bright and shiny, but softening by the hour. If you’ve ever found yourself with more fresh produce than you can handle, you know that mix of excitement and panic. I couldn’t bear to throw them away. But I also didn’t have the time or patience to make a sauce or a salad.

So I did what I often do in the kitchen: I started improvising.

I remember the exact moment it all came together. I reached for my favorite skillet, poured in a swirl of olive oil, and tipped those tomatoes in. They sizzled immediately, and the kitchen filled with that unmistakable smell of tomatoes meeting heat – sweet, tangy, and rich all at once. I sprinkled over a pinch of sea salt and some red pepper flakes, not too much, just enough to wake up their natural flavor. As they cooked, I gently pressed down with the back of a spoon, encouraging them to release their juices. Watching them transform from firm little globes into jammy, blistered bursts of summer was pure joy.

cherry tomatoes with olive oil and red pepper flakes in skillet

While the tomatoes worked their magic, I sliced into a rustic sourdough loaf, the kind with a thick, golden crust that shatters when you bite into it. I toasted it just enough to make it crisp on the outside while keeping it tender inside. Then I reached for a ripe avocado, cut it in half, and scooped the soft green flesh into a bowl. A squeeze of lemon, a little salt, and a quick mash with a fork turned it into a silky spread, still with a few chunks for texture.

avocado half in a bowl, hand is squeezing the lemon

And because I believe that the best dishes are layered with unexpected flavors, I opened a jar of basil pesto I’d made earlier that week. That vibrant green, fragrant with garlic and nuts and oil, was exactly the kind of bright note the toast needed. I spread it onto the bread, followed with the avocado, spooned on a generous helping of those warm, jammy tomatoes, and finished it all off with crumbles of salty feta and a scattering of fresh oregano leaves from my little windowsill herb pot.

The first bite? It was one of those moments that makes you close your eyes and savor. The crunch of the bread, the creaminess of the avocado, the sweet and tangy tomatoes bursting with flavor, the herby pesto underneath, and the salty bite of feta on top – it was all there. This wasn’t just a quick lunch; it was something memorable.

Since then, I’ve made this toast countless times. Sometimes I serve it as an easy breakfast when I want something more exciting than plain avocado toast. Other times it’s a light lunch with a side salad or even a simple dinner with a poached egg on top. It has also become one of my go-to recipes when friends stop by unexpectedly. There’s something impressive about handing someone a plate with this colorful, layered toast. Even though it only takes minutes to put together, it feels like something you’d order at a trendy café.

Why this toast is worth making over and over

The real secret of this dish is the blistered tomatoes. Cooking them quickly over medium heat until their skins crack and their juices thicken creates a topping that’s sweet, savory, and deeply flavorful. The best part is that you can cook a batch ahead of time and keep them in the fridge for a couple of days. That means you can have this toast whenever you want without starting from scratch each time.

There’s also something special about how these simple ingredients play together. The basil pesto acts like a bridge between the rich avocado and the tomatoes, adding a freshness that keeps everything tasting light and bright. The feta brings just enough saltiness to balance out the sweetness of the tomatoes, and the oregano leaves give you that final burst of herbal fragrance that lingers with each bite.

How I learned to perfect it

The first time I made this toast, I was just happy I’d saved my tomatoes. But as I made it again and again, I started to refine the technique. I learned that cooking the tomatoes too fast over high heat can burn their skins before the insides soften, so medium heat is perfect. Then, I discovered that gently pressing on them with a spoon as they cook helps them release their juices and speeds up that jammy transformation.

I also experimented with different breads and learned that sourdough is ideal. Its sturdy structure holds up to all the toppings without getting soggy. And its subtle tang pairs beautifully with the pesto and tomatoes. When I’m feeling adventurous, I grill the bread instead of toasting it – there’s something about those char marks and that smoky edge that makes the toast even better.

The avocado mash is another place where little tweaks make a big difference. I used to just smash it onto the toast, but adding lemon juice and a pinch of salt brightens it up and keeps it from tasting flat. Sometimes I even stir in a few torn basil leaves or a drizzle of olive oil for extra richness.

Making it part of your routine

What I love most about this toast is how flexible it is. It fits into so many different moments. In the morning, when I want something filling but fresh, I make it as-is with a hot coffee on the side. On a busy afternoon, it’s my go-to when I need lunch but don’t have the energy for something complicated. If I’m entertaining, I cut the bread into smaller slices and make mini versions as appetizers.

Because the blistered tomatoes can be cooked in advance, this toast is also perfect for meal prep. On Sunday night, I’ll cook up a batch of tomatoes and keep them in an airtight container in the fridge. Then, during the week, all I have to do is toast the bread, mash the avocado, and assemble. It feels luxurious even on the busiest days.

Tips for getting the most out of your ingredients

One of the joys of cooking is discovering how each step can make a difference. With this recipe, it’s all about respecting each component. Use ripe tomatoes – they’re the star of the show. Don’t rush them in the skillet; let them sizzle gently until they’re soft and bursting. Choose good bread, something that feels sturdy and artisanal, because it’s the foundation. And if you can, use a good olive oil – its flavor will shine through in those blistered tomatoes.

The same goes for the pesto and feta. A homemade pesto is fantastic if you have time, but a high-quality store-bought one works beautifully. And when it comes to feta, look for one that’s creamy and tangy. I like to crumble it with my fingers rather than using pre-crumbled feta. It melts into the tomatoes and avocado in such a lovely way.

When to serve it

Honestly, I think this toast is good any time of day. I’ve eaten it standing at the kitchen counter for a quick breakfast. I’ve served it as part of a sunny brunch spread with friends, where everyone reaches for seconds. I also had it late at night after a long day, when I wanted something comforting but not heavy. The flavors are so vibrant and satisfying that it feels right in almost any situation.

Questions you might have

People often ask me if they can make this toast ahead of time. While you can prep the components – like the blistered tomatoes – this is definitely a dish best assembled right before serving. That’s when the bread is at its crunchiest and the contrast between the warm tomatoes and cool avocado is most pronounced.

Others wonder if they can use a different cheese. Absolutely. Goat cheese is lovely here, with its creamy tang. Ricotta works too, giving you a milder flavor. Even a few shavings of Parmesan can add a wonderful salty bite.

If you don’t have sourdough, don’t worry. Ciabatta or even a hearty whole-grain bread can stand in. Just make sure it’s thick enough to hold all those toppings.

And if you’re sensitive to heat, skip the red pepper flakes. The toast will still be packed with flavor, just a little gentler.

A dish worth sharing

What started as a way to use up a surplus of tomatoes has become one of those recipes I return to again and again. It’s simple, yes, but it feels special every time I make it. It’s a reminder that with a little creativity, you can turn everyday ingredients into something extraordinary.

So next time you have a handful of cherry tomatoes waiting to be used, give this toast a try. Take your time blistering those tomatoes, let their juices thicken and caramelize just a bit. Mash your avocado with care, toast your bread until it’s golden, and don’t be shy with the feta. When you take that first bite, I hope you’ll feel the same spark of joy I did the very first time I made it.

Final thoughts

Cooking is never just about feeding yourself – it’s about creating little moments of comfort and connection. This Toast with Basil Pesto, Avocado, Blistered Tomatoes and Feta Crumbs is one of those recipes that turns an ordinary day into something worth savoring. It’s quick enough for a weekday but special enough to serve to friends. It’s a dish that lets summer ingredients shine and reminds you why simple food is often the best food.

If you make this toast, I would truly love to hear from you. Share your photos, your little tweaks, the moments you enjoyed it – those are the stories that make sharing recipes so meaningful! Here’s to many delicious slices of toast in your future. Enjoy!